The below article is reproduced from as is because it is a must read for everyone & anyone who wants to see real time proof of the devastation being caused by Wal-Mart and similar big box stores, who simply decimate the economy of almost every community that they move into.
Excerpted from "Happy  City"
Jobs, Money, and Geometry
Most of us agree that development that provides employment and tax revenue is good for cities. Some even argue that the need for jobs outweighs aesthetic, lifestyle, or climate concerns—in fact, this argument comes up any time Walmart proposes a new megastore near a small town. But a clear-eyed look at the spatial economics of land, jobs, and tax regimes should cause anyone to reject the anything-and-anywhere-goes development model. To explain, let me offer the story of an obsessive number cruncher who found his own urban laboratory quite by chance.

 Joseph Minicozzi, a young architect raised in upstate New York, was on a cross-country motorcycle ride in 2001 when he got sidetracked in the Appalachian Mountains. He met a beautiful woman in a North Carolina roadside bar and was smitten by both that woman and the languid beauty of the Blue Ridge region. Now they share a bungalow with two dogs in the mountain town of Asheville.

Asheville is, in many ways, a typical midsize American city, which is to say that its downtown was virtually abandoned in the second half of the twentieth century. Dozens of elegant old structures were boarded up or encased in aluminum siding as highways and liberal development policies sucked people and commercial life into dispersal. The process continued until 1991, when Julian Price, the heir to a family insurance and broadcasting fortune, decided to pour everything he had
into nursing that old downtown back to life. His company, Public Interest Projects, bought and renovated old buildings, leased street-front space out to small businesses, and rented or sold the lofts above to a new wave of residential pioneers. They coached, coddled, and sometimes bankrolled entrepreneurs who began to enliven the streets. First came a vegetarian restaurant, then a bookstore, a furniture store, and the now-legendary nightclub, the Orange Peel.

When Price died in 2001, the downtown was starting to show signs of life, but his successor, Pat Whelan, and his new recruit, Minicozzi, still had to battle the civic skeptics. Some city officials saw such little value in downtown land that they planned to plunk down a prison right in the middle of a terrain that was perfect for mixed-use redevelopment. The developers realized that if they wanted the city officials to support their vision, they needed to educate them—and that meant offering them hard numbers on the tax and job benefits of revitalizing 
downtown. The numbers they produced sparked a eureka moment among the city’s accountants because they insisted on taking a spatial systems approach, similar to the way farmers look at land they want to put into production. The question was simple: What is the production yield for every acre of land? On a farm, the answer might be in pounds of tomatoes. In the city, it’s about tax revenues and

To explain, Minicozzi offered me his classic urban accounting smackdown, using two competing properties: On the one side is a downtown building his firm rescued—a six-story steel-framed 1923 classic once owned by JCPenney and converted into shops, offices, and condos. On the other side is a Walmart on the edge of town. The old Penney’s building sits on less than a quarter of an acre, while the Walmart and its parking lots occupy thirty-four acres. Adding up the property and sales tax paid on each piece of land, Minicozzi found that the Walmart contributed only $50,800 to the city in retail and property taxes for each acre it used, but the JCPenney building contributed a whopping $330,000 per acre in property tax alone. In other words, the city got more than seven times the return for every acre on downtown investments than it did when it broke new ground out on the city limits.

When Minicozzi looked at job density, the difference was even more vivid: the small businesses that occupied the old Penney’s building employed fourteen people, which doesn’t seem like many until you realize that this is actually seventy-four jobs per acre, compared with the fewer than six jobs per acre created on a sprawling Walmart site. (This is particularly dire given that on top of reducing jobs density in its host cities, Walmart depresses average wages as well.)

 Minicozzi has since found the same spatial conditions in cities all over the United States. Even low-rise, mixed-use buildings of two or three stories—the kind you see on an old-style, small-town main street—bring in ten times the revenue per acre as that of an average big-box development. What’s stunning is that, thanks to the relationship between energy and distance, large-footprint sprawl development patterns can actually cost cities more to service than they give back in taxes. The result? Growth that produces deficits that simply cannot be overcome with new growth revenue.*

 “Cities and counties have essentially been taking tax revenues from downtowns and using them to subsidize development and services in sprawl,” Minicozzi told me. “This is like a farmer going out and dumping all his fertilizer on the weeds rather than on the tomatoes.”**

 Price, Whelan, and Minicozzi helped convince the city of Asheville to fertilize that rich downtown soil. The city changed its zoning policies, allowing flexible uses for downtown buildings. It invested in livelier streetscapes and public events. It stopped forcing developers to build parking garages, which brought down the cost of both housing and business. It built its own user-pay garages, so the cost of parking was borne by the people who used it rather than by everyone else. All of this helped make it worthwhile for developers to risk their investment on restoring old buildings, producing new jobs and tax density for the city.

 Retail sales in the resurgent downtown have exploded since 1991. So has the taxable value of downtown properties, which cost a fraction to service than sprawl lands. The reborn downtown has become the greatest supplier of tax revenue and affordable housing in the county—partly because it relieves people of the burden of commuting, and partly because it mixes high-end lofts with modest apartments. All of this, while growing what one local newspaper emotionally described as, “a  downtown that—after decades of doubt and neglect—is once again the heart and soul of Asheville.”


01/20/2014 3:08pm

To explain, let me offer the story of an obsessive number cruncher who found his own urban laboratory quite by chance.

01/24/2014 10:28am

Design-Fabrication & Consultant Engineers takes immense pride in revealing that it has gained a wide recognition as a quality supplier of straightening machine, that too in a very short span of time. There are various types of straightening machine including round bar straightening, tube straightening, angle straightening, channel straightening, special section straightening, etc. We do supply most of the high performance straightening machines which is mainly used for straightening the bars, wires, etc.

Though, the machine supplied by us is available in diverse specifications, but we also take into consideration the customized requirements of our esteemed clients in order to deliver them the value of money. You can expect high speed from the machines manufactured by us. Robust construction is yet another strong feature that will certainly compel you to place your order with us. When you are getting superior quality machine, offering low maintenance cost then why to lag behind and think much?

Design-Fabrication & Consultant Engineers has produced highly satisfied customers all over the world and you could be one among them by relying on us. So, what are you waiting for? Just let us know your requirements and we assure you that we will cater to you in a best possible manner.

08/05/2014 11:19pm

With such games, one could either play against other people or a computer. If a person goes up against a machine, it would contain thousands or millions of card combinations.

08/05/2014 11:38pm

Only visit the online casinos or their offline counterparts with money that you can afford to lose. People who disobey this unwritten rule of responsible gambling inevitably end up making poor decisions.

08/05/2014 11:44pm

The Ten Top Casino Guide Online is the list of online casinos that offer only casino sites with large networks.

11/10/2014 10:00pm

There is little doubt regarding it, poker chips square measure a part of the finer things in life. thus try and get the simplest and continue your name within the world of poker.<strong><a href="">POKER AT HOME</a></strong>

11/10/2014 10:08pm

The world of online casinos seems to be booming in the UK at the moment. More and more people are getting in on the action, and consequently more and more online casinos are opening as a result.

11/10/2014 10:13pm

Since the internet is flooding with rogue casino websites, if you do not select a legit site your hard earned money can be wasted.

12/30/2014 1:00am

The internet currently permits individuals to play on-line poker from where they live. there’s no would like of traveling to a casino as there square measure several on-line casinos offered on the web.

12/30/2014 3:36am

Online poker is in the same regard, protected from most people being able to bargain their website, however, a individual experienced in the art of development can quickly understand how to use online poker tools to subvert the protection application designed to avoid unfaithful, collusion and poker bot recognition.

01/25/2015 10:57pm

Currently there ar four poker channels that may be viewed by UK Sky subscribers and over two hundred poker sites that may be vie round the globe, creating on-line gambling a sort of diversion and recreation that ranks aboard the cinema and bowling in terms of visits.

01/25/2015 10:58pm

There is little doubt regarding it, poker chips square measure a part of the finer things in life. thus try and get the simplest and continue your name within the world of poker.

01/25/2015 10:59pm

The online pokies have managed to bring a lot of benefits, especially since they have become very fast an important source of entertainment all over the world and especially in Australia. The termpokies is the Australian version of slot game.

04/05/2015 11:46pm

The game begins when each player is dealt by two face-down pocket cards by the dealer and the first limit of bets begins. This part of Texas Holdem Poker is called preposition.

04/12/2015 8:43pm

The game begins when each player is dealt by two face-down pocket cards by the dealer and the first limit of bets begins. This part of Texas Holdem Poker is called preposition.

04/12/2015 8:45pm

If youre unaccustomed casino gambling, chances are high that, square measure} thinking that you simply are enclosed by aliens United Nations agency speak a distinct language.

04/12/2015 8:47pm

Poker comes in an exceedingly range of designs that play on the foundations simply alittle consistent with the variation. There area unit some extremely popular poker games that any player can wish to understand so as to feel snug at any poker table.

04/16/2015 11:13pm

Poker chips have become the most popular and mandatory things in every casino. These poker chips will be coming in numerous models and textures according to the type of casino using them. This article deals with the specifications of the casino poker chips.

04/16/2015 11:14pm

Online Poker is while not a doubt one amongst the foremost convenient and best ways that to play poker being that you simply neer need to leave your house and you’ll bring the texture of Vegas into your house and ne’er amendment out of your pajamas. whereas it should not hold identical excitement as ancient face to face casinos it’s still convenient none the less.

04/16/2015 11:17pm

Online casinos have managed to supply enthusiasts variety of engaging edges. From convenience to high jackpots, players have learned to come back to understand on-line casinos as a supply of recreation from their homes, workplace and – currently – their cell phones. Mobile casinos permit people to play a range of various casino games from variety of varied mobile devices.

06/17/2015 2:14am

There are quite a few reasons to learn how to play online poker. One of the most important things to remember is that this is a skill game.

06/17/2015 2:15am

If youre attempting to work out wherever to play on-line poker games, do an internet|an on-line|a webhunt for online poker rooms and take a glance at a number of the web poker-related websites that have elaborated poker site reviews and ratings on their pages.

06/17/2015 2:16am

Thus, there exists an option for newcomers for playing free poker games that do not involve betting with real money. This is a great option to enhance their skills.

06/17/2015 2:17am

Poker players always search for new methods and techniques to improve their game and win huge cash prizes. Below are some tips that will help you improve your poker playing skills.


Process of the study and academics is linked and connected with the research and innovation of the ideas. It is skills of the experts that are responsible for the success of the entire society and community.

04/30/2017 5:53am

Thank you very much for the info agan convey and hopefully useful to my friend who read it.
and for a friend


Leave a Reply